Skip to main content
The University of Chicago

Utility

  • Log in
  • Directory
    • Hire Harris Overview
    • Find Talent
    • Find Work
    • Info For Overview
    • Alumni
    • Admitted Students
    • Current Students
    • EMP Students
    • Faculty and Staff
    • Media
    • Make a Gift Overview
    • Ways to Give
    • Annual Fund
    • The Harris Society
    • Meet Our Team
Sort

Main navigation

  • About Overview
    • Who We Are Who We Are Overview
      • Who We Are Overview
      • Career Outcomes
      • Harris By The Numbers
      • The Keller Center
      • Awards
    • Leadership Leadership Overview
      • Leadership Overview
      • Alumni Council
      • Dean's Office
      • Harris Council
      • Meet The Dean
    • History History Overview
      • History Overview
      • History of Harris
      • Legacy of Irving B. Harris

    Considering Applying?

    Get a jump start now by creating an account with our simple online tool.

    Get Started

    Still have questions? Check out Admissions for details on requirements, deadlines, and financial aid.

  • Academics Overview
    • Degree Programs Degree Programs Overview
      • Degree Programs Overview
      • Master of Public Policy (MPP)
      • MS in Computational Analysis and Public Policy
      • MA in Public Policy with Certificate in Research Methods
      • Evening Master's Program (Part-time MA)
      • MA in Public Policy
      • PhD
      • Joint Degree Programs
    • Non-Degree Programs Non-Degree Programs Overview
      • Non-Degree Programs Overview
      • Credential Programs
      • Civic Leadership Academy
    • Undergraduate Program Undergraduate Program Overview
      • Undergraduate Program Overview
      • Overview
      • BA Thesis Process
      • Capstone Projects
      • Community Highlights
      • Team
    • Courses Courses Overview
      • Courses Overview
      • Non-Harris Student Registration
    • Design Your Path Design Your Path Overview
      • Design Your Path Overview
      • Core Curriculum
      • Practical Experience
      • Specializations
      • Policy Areas
      • Workshops
      • Academic Calendar
      • University of Chicago Obama Foundation Scholars

    Considering Applying?

    Get a jump start now by creating an account with our simple online tool.

    Get Started

    Still have questions? Check out Admissions for details on requirements, deadlines, and financial aid.

  • Admissions Overview
    • Why Public Policy?
    • Applying to Harris Applying to Harris Overview
      • Applying to Harris Overview
      • International Students
      • FAQ
      • Admissions Resources
      • Harris Scholars Program
    • Requirements & Deadlines
    • Meet with Harris Meet with Harris Overview
      • Meet with Harris Overview
      • Connect with Our Students
      • Masterclass Series
      • Meet Our Staff
      • Schedule a Visit
      • Travel Reimbursement
    • Financing Your Degree Financing Your Degree Overview
      • Financing Your Degree Overview
      • Scholarships & Fellowships
      • Loans & Work-Study
      • Third-Party Funding
      • Tuition & Expenses
    • Admissions Blog
    • Request Information

    Considering Applying?

    Get a jump start now by creating an account with our simple online tool.

    Get Started

    Still have questions? Check out Admissions for details on requirements, deadlines, and financial aid.

  • Student Life Overview
    • What to Expect What to Expect Overview
      • What to Expect Overview
      • From Orientation to Graduation
      • Connect with Your Community
    • Student Engagement & Belonging Student Engagement & Belonging Overview
      • Student Engagement & Belonging Overview
      • City of Chicago
      • Meet the Student Engagement & Belonging Team
      • Mentor Program
      • Our Campus Community
      • Student Organizations
    • Career Development Career Development Overview
      • Career Development Overview
      • Career Resources
      • Alumni Career Support
      • Internship Program
      • Career Development FAQ
      • Meet the CDO Team
    • Dean of Students Office Dean of Students Office Overview
      • Dean of Students Office Overview
      • Academic Advising
      • Harris Writing Workshop
      • Academic Support Programs
      • Meet the Dean of Students Office
      • Student Emergency Resources
      • Policies

    Considering Applying?

    Get a jump start now by creating an account with our simple online tool.

    Get Started

    Still have questions? Check out Admissions for details on requirements, deadlines, and financial aid.

  • Research & Impact Overview
    • Centers & Institutes Centers & Institutes Overview
      • Centers & Institutes Overview
      • Center for Economic Policy
      • Center for Effective Government
      • Center for Health Policy
      • Center for Human Potential and Public Policy (CHPPP)
      • Center for Impact Sciences
      • Center for Municipal Finance
      • Center for Survey Methodology
      • Center for the Economics of Human Development
      • Energy Policy Institute at the University of Chicago (EPIC)
      • International Innovation Corps
      • Stone Center for Research on Wealth Inequality and Mobility
      • The Pearson Institute
      • Urban Labs
      • Affiliated Centers
    • Faculty Impact Faculty Impact Overview
      • Faculty Impact Overview
      • Nobel Prize Winning Faculty
      • Faculty Directory
      • Expert Guide
    • Initiatives & Partnerships Initiatives & Partnerships Overview
      • Initiatives & Partnerships Overview
      • Cyber Policy Initiative
      • Technology and Society Initiative ↗

    Considering Applying?

    Get a jump start now by creating an account with our simple online tool.

    Get Started

    Still have questions? Check out Admissions for details on requirements, deadlines, and financial aid.

  • News & Events Overview
    • News News Overview
      • News Overview
      • News
      • Profile
      • Research
      • In the News
      • Admissions Blog
    • Events Events Overview
      • Events Overview
      • Academic Conferences
      • Admissions Events
      • Alumni Events
      • Student Events
      • Special Events
      • Visiting Speakers
      • Past Events
    • Podcasts Podcasts Overview
      • Podcasts Overview
      • Not Another Politics Podcast
      • The Inequality Podcast
      • Public Money Pod
    • Newsletters Newsletters Overview
      • Newsletters Overview
      • Harris Connect: Alumni Newsletter
      • Not Another Politics Newsletter
      • Pointed: Policy Research Newsletter
      • Public Money Policy Newsletter

    Considering Applying?

    Get a jump start now by creating an account with our simple online tool.

    Get Started

    Still have questions? Check out Admissions for details on requirements, deadlines, and financial aid.

Utility

  • Log in
  • Directory
    • Hire Harris Overview
    • Find Talent
    • Find Work
    • Info For Overview
    • Alumni
    • Admitted Students
    • Current Students
    • EMP Students
    • Faculty and Staff
    • Media
    • Make a Gift Overview
    • Ways to Give
    • Annual Fund
    • The Harris Society
    • Meet Our Team

Death and the Great Migration

Great Migration
August 01, 2014
Research
Aimee Levitt
A new study finds that African Americans who left the South in the early twentieth century died younger than those who stayed

When Chicago Harris Professor and Deputy Dean Dan Black started researching the impact of the Great Migration on African American longevity, he had a pretty good idea of the results he and his colleagues would find.

They already knew that African Americans who migrated from the rural South to northern cities made more money, nearly double the income of their peers who stayed in the South. Migrants were a self-selected group: many of them had been preparing all their lives to make the move. They had stayed in school longer. They were physically stronger. “Everything suggested they’d be healthier than their counterparts in the South,” Black says. “The American South pre-1964 was a terrible place to be a black person. Hospitals wouldn’t see you. Doctors wouldn’t treat you. You had to have been better off moving north.”

But in terms of longevity, the migrants weren’t better off at all. In fact, on average, they died a year and a half sooner.

When Seth Sanders of Duke University shared the results, Black recalls, he was shocked. More than four years later, he still shakes his head in amazement. “I said, ‘Look at that program again.’ He said, ‘I did.’ I was flabbergasted. You could have made some serious money taking a bet against me.”

As Black thought about the results, though, they started to make more sense. The data used by Black, Sanders and their colleagues Lowell Taylor of Carnegie Mellon and Evan Taylor (Lowell’s son), a graduate student at the University of Michigan, came from the Duke SSA/Medicare Dataset, a collection of 70 million records from the Social Security Numerical Identification Files and Medicare Part B. They contain information about race, sex and age – and, crucially, place of birth and death.

Most migrants came north on the railroads. There were three main streams: the coastal South to the Northeast and Washington,D.C.; Alabama and Mississippi to the Midwest; and Louisiana to California. Black and his colleagues reasoned that most migrants had come from towns near the railroad lines. By looking at old railroad maps, they were able to find links between “sending communities” and “receiving communities.” Then they devised a formula to compare the longevity of people who had stayed versus that of those who had left, limiting themselves to people born between 1916 and 1932 in eight states in the Deep South. “A huge part of the work was getting the data prepared,” Black says.

No matter how they analyzed the data – eliminating the larger cities, using sending communities that were farther from the railroad lines, looking at just men or just women – it always came out the same: migrants who lived to 65 were less likely to make it to 70 or 75. But why?

The answer was found in the Detailed Mortality Files of the U.S. Vital Statistics registry. By looking at that data, Black discovered that migrants were dying at much higher rates from cirrhosis and pulmonary illnesses. Information from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System showed that black men and women born in the Deep South between 1916 and 1932 who migrated north were more likely to smoke and drink than those who stayed in the South.

Suddenly it became clear: if you have money, you can afford to buy cigarettes and booze. As Black notes, “Money is a great thing. You can buy lots of stuff, and not all of it’s good for you.”

There were other factors as well: chemicals and pollution from factories, higher population density (and, therefore, more contagious diseases), the shock of colder weather, the stress from a higher cost of living. However, Evan Taylor and Janna Johnson (PhD’12) had studied white migrants from the Great Plains to the West Coast and noted that they smoked and drank more, too, and had higher rates of cirrhosis and pulmonary disease without the other mitigating factors.

The paper, forthcoming in American Economic Review, has already generated interest at conferences and among colleagues. “When I first heard about it,” says Kerwin Charles, Edwin A. and Betty L. Bergman Distinguished Service Professor and Deputy Dean at Harris, “I said, ‘That’s wrong, that can’t be right.’ The paper does a powerful job of convincing you, at least empirically. It changed my view entirely of what was going on in the Great Migration. ”

For the next phase of the study, Black plans to look at the second generation born in Chicago, and how they compare to their counterparts from Mississippi. “I hope there’s a brighter outcome,” he says. 

Related stories

The Policy Entrepreneur

April 13, 2018

Equality, You're on the Air

April 01, 2015
Anne Richard

Tackling the Global Refugee Crisis

April 01, 2016
thumbnail

It's Almost Bedtime. Have You Read to Your Child Yet?

August 01, 2014

America's Hidden Hunger Crisis

August 01, 2014
  • Prospective Students
    • How to Apply
    • Why Public Policy
    • Financial Aid
    • Events
  • Current Students
    • Academic Advising
    • Policies
    • Courses
    • Disability Resources
  • Faculty & Staff
    • Room Reservations
    • Academic Calendar
    • Faculty Resources
    • Faculty Access
    • Human Resources
  • Alumni
    • News and Events
    • Alumni Directory
    • Get Involved
    • Donate Now
Back to Top
The University of Chicago

Connect with Us

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • Youtube
  • Instagram

Questions?

Contact Us

Footer menu

  • Apply
  • Careers at Harris
  • Courses
  • Directions
  • Privacy Notice
  • Accessibility
  • Refer a Student